MailGenius vs MailMoxie Pricing: Which Email Testing Tool Offers Better Value in 2025?

Choosing between MailGenius and MailMoxie? Here’s a clear pricing breakdown and why one offers better value for most teams.

MailGenius Pricing Breakdown (2025)

Free — $0/month

• 3 email tests/month
• Basic spam score
• SPF/DKIM/DMARC checks
• No recommendations, no accessibility, no AI

Pro — $49/month

• Unlimited tests
• Advanced spam scoring
• Blacklist monitoring
• Inbox placement testing
• HTML validation
• Still no AI or accessibility

Agency — $99/month

• Everything in Pro
• Multiple users, priority support, API access
• Still no AI

Bottom line: $588–$1,188/year for technical testing without modern AI insights.

MailMoxie Pricing: The Game Changer

Free Trial — $0

• 1 email test
• No credit card required

MailMoxie Pro — $20/month

• Unlimited email tests
• AI-powered analysis & recommendations
• 50+ spam trigger testing
• WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility testing
• Subject line optimization
• Personal agent email
• Instant results

Side-by-Side Summary

• Monthly cost: MailGenius $49–$99 vs MailMoxie Free $0 or Pro $20
• Email tests: MailGenius Unlimited vs MailMoxie Unlimited
• AI analysis: MailGenius ✗ vs MailMoxie ✓
• Accessibility: MailGenius ✗ vs MailMoxie ✓
• Personal agent email: MailGenius ✗ vs MailMoxie ✓

Hidden Costs with MailGenius

• Time to interpret raw data without guidance
• Higher learning curve for technical features
• Limited free tier (only 3 tests)

Final Verdict

MailGenius charges up to $1,188/year without AI or accessibility. MailMoxie provides more advanced capabilities completely free, with Pro $20/month for teams needing support—delivering far better value and faster outcomes.