MailGenius vs MailMoxie Pricing: Which Email Testing Tool Offers Better Value in 2025?

July 6, 2025

Email deliverability testing is crucial for any serious email marketing campaign, but with so many tools available, it's hard to know which one offers the best value for your money. In this comprehensive pricing comparison, we'll break down exactly what you get with MailGenius vs MailMoxie, so you can make an informed decision about where to invest your marketing budget.

MailGenius Pricing Breakdown and Comparison (2025)

MailGenius offers three pricing tiers, each with different features and limitations. Let's examine what you actually get for your money:

Free Plan

$0/month

✓3 email tests per month

✓Basic spam score

✓SPF/DKIM/DMARC checks

✗No detailed recommendations

✗No accessibility testing

✗No AI-powered insights

Bottom line: Good for occasional testing, but severely limited for serious email marketers.

Pro Plan

$49/month

✓Unlimited email tests

✓Advanced spam scoring

✓Blacklist monitoring

✓Inbox placement testing

✓HTML validation

✗Still no AI recommendations

✗No accessibility testing

Bottom line: $588/year for technical testing without actionable insights.

Agency Plan

$99/month

✓Everything in Pro

✓Multiple user accounts

✓Priority support

✓API access

✗Still no AI-powered analysis

Bottom line: $1,188/year for team features, but still missing modern AI capabilities.

MailMoxie Pricing: The Game Changer

Now let's look at what MailMoxie offers and how it completely changes the pricing conversation:

MailMoxie - Free Forever Plan

$0/month

What You Get:

✓Unlimited email tests

✓AI-powered analysis & recommendations

✓50+ spam trigger testing

✓WCAG 2.1 AA accessibility testing

✓Subject line optimization

✓Personal agent email address

✓Instant results (seconds, not minutes)

✓No credit card required

Advanced Features:

✓Marketing email optimization

✓Transactional email testing

✓Detailed improvement suggestions

✓Email content analysis

✓Best practices recommendations

✓Mobile responsiveness checks

Side-by-Side Pricing Comparison

Feature	MailGenius Free	MailGenius Pro	MailGenius Agency	MailMoxie
Monthly Cost	$0	$49	$99	$0
Annual Cost	$0	$588	$1,188	$0
Email Tests	3/month	Unlimited	Unlimited	Unlimited
AI Analysis	✗	✗	✗	✓
Accessibility Testing	✗	✗	✗	✓
Subject Line Optimization	✗	✗	✗	✓
Personal Agent Email	✗	✗	✗	✓
Credit Card Required	✗	✓	✓	✗

The Hidden Costs of MailGenius

When comparing pricing, it's important to look beyond just the monthly fee. Here are the hidden costs that make MailGenius more expensive than it appears:

Time Investment

MailGenius gives you raw data but no actionable insights. You'll spend hours interpreting results and figuring out what to fix, costing you valuable time that could be spent on other marketing activities.

Learning Curve

Technical features like SPF/DKIM/DMARC require IT knowledge to implement. You might need to hire a developer or spend time learning technical email infrastructure.

Limited Free Tier

Only 3 tests per month means you'll quickly outgrow the free plan and be forced to pay $49/month just to test your emails regularly.

Missing Modern Features

No AI analysis means you're missing out on the latest email optimization techniques. Your competitors using AI-powered tools will have an advantage.

Real-World Cost Comparison

Scenario: Small Marketing Team (5 people)

MailGenius Agency Plan

For team collaboration

$1,188/year

+ time for manual analysis

MailMoxie

Unlimited team access

$0/year

+ instant AI insights

Savings with MailMoxie: $1,188 per year, plus countless hours saved on manual analysis and implementation.

Why MailMoxie's Pricing Model is Revolutionary

Democratizing Email Testing

By making advanced email testing completely free, MailMoxie is leveling the playing field. Small businesses and startups can now access the same powerful tools that were previously only available to enterprise companies with big budgets.

No Risk, All Reward

Unlike MailGenius which requires a credit card and monthly commitment, MailMoxie lets you start testing immediately with no financial risk. You can test as many emails as you want without worrying about hitting limits or unexpected charges.

Future-Proof Technology

While MailGenius focuses on traditional technical testing, MailMoxie incorporates cutting-edge AI technology that will only get smarter over time. You're not just getting a tool for today, but a platform that evolves with email marketing best practices.

Final Verdict: The Clear Winner

When you look at the numbers, the choice is clear. MailGenius charges up to $1,188 per year for features that are either limited or missing entirely, while MailMoxie provides more advanced capabilities completely free.

But it's not just about the money. MailMoxie's AI-powered approach saves you time, provides better insights, and helps you actually improve your email performance rather than just giving you raw data to figure out yourself.

Ready to Save $1,188+ Per Year?

Join thousands of marketers who've already switched to MailMoxie and are getting better results for free.

No credit card required • No monthly fees • No limits

Disclosure: This pricing comparison is based on publicly available information as of January 2025. MailGenius pricing information was sourced from their official pricing page. We recommend verifying current pricing before making any purchasing decisions.